Berry Hill and the Johnson Family

Berry Hill - Home of Joseph H. Johnson (1827-1893) and his wife Elmira Andrews (1831-1867) or (1836-1869)
 

According to "Antebellum Orange" by Ann Miller, Joseph Johnson purchased Berry Hill in 1872 and lived there until his death in 1893. His wife Elmira Andrews Johnson died in 1869 and she, along with her infant daughter Fannie, are buried in the same grave in Graham Cemetery. Berry Hill still stands and was owned by Joseph Johnson’s granddaughter, Jo Williams Hill and her husband, Rowland Hill until 1986 when it was purchased by the Taylor family. Berry Hill acreage was once a part of the original 1722 land grant to Colonel James Taylor II, and at one time was owned by the grandfather and namesake of President Zachary Taylor.

Children of Joseph and Elmira:

Wallace (1855-1860) 
Lelia married Walker W. Sanford
Evelyn married William C. Williams
Blanche married William D Row
J. Weister married Loulie MacDonald
Fannie (died as an infant and buried with her mother in Graham Cemetery)

 

Sunning Hill - Home of Joseph H. Johnson prior to move to Berry Hill
 

Sunning Hill located in Louisa County was purchased in 1867 by Joseph H. Johnson and Henry Quarles, the half-brother of his wife Elmira Andrews Johnson.  It was later sold to Joseph Johnson’s brother Thaddeus and Thaddeus' son Munford, after which Joseph and his family moved to Berry Hill. It appears that Lelia was born at Sunning Hill.

According to researcher Claudia Anderson Chisholm of Louisa County:

The next period of permanent tenure was that of the Johnson family. In 1863 Joseph H. Johnson and Henry Quarles obtained the three tracts of Minor property with an agreement that in the event either should die, Quarles was to take the Spotsylvania and Duckinghold tracts and Johnson the Sunning Hill tract. Unfortunately, Quarles died before deeding the said tract. A law suit settlement in 1866 retained Sunning Hill in the Johnson family.

During the next thirty-three years, various members of the Johnson family owned Sunning Hill. Johnson owners were Joseph H. Johnson of Orange County, 1866-1885; Thaddeus T. Johnson, 1885-1898; Mumsford S. Johnson and wife, Mamie E. of Louisa County, 1898-1899. By 1905, John N. Walker had purchased all three tracts from the Johnson heirs.

Sunning Hill still exists today, once again a private residence.

 

Andrews Tavern - Home of Elmira Andrews (wife of Joe Johnson)
 

Elmira Andrews Johnson was born at Andrews Tavern, located in Spotsylvania County. Her father William Harris Andrews managed the farm that supplied the tavern, while William's brother Samuel Andrews managed the tavern.  Samuel Andrews is buried in the graveyard on the site.

Elmira Elizabeth Andrews (1831-1867) was the daughter of William Harris Andrews and Mary Elizabeth Anderson Quarles (1806-1869). She is buried in Graham Cemetery.

 

 Children of William Harris and Mary Elizabeth Quarles Andrews were:

John Quarles Andrews (1829-1859) Drowned in Texas
ELMIRA ELIZABETH ANDREWS (1831-1867) married Joe Johnson
Roberta Andrews (1833-?) Married William Garnett
Armelia Landonia Andrews (1835-1853) married Joseph Brock
Wilmonia Eudora Andrews (?-1927) married James Mordecai Moore
Mary Isabella Andrews (1838-1874)

(Note: The Ben Sanford family values very highly a small walnut trunk or chest that Ben purchased at the auction of Cousin Mabel and Willie Moore’s property in 1959 in the Town of Orange. Mabel and Willie were daughters of Wilmonia Eudora Andrews and James Moore. The trunk was said to have been one of three built by an uncle for three of the Andrews sisters, probably their hope chest. This story was told to us by Cousin Rowland Hill who added that the base of one of these chest was removed and it was put down in a closet to hide the family silver from the Yankees during the War between the States. I think I recall him saying that he and Cousin Jo had one of the chest and Aunt Lelia had another.)

John Andrews (1765-1802) who married Elizabeth Lipscomb in 1792

John and Elizabeth were the parents of at least six children. Among these children are William Harris Andrews and John Day Andrews (17951882) who went to Texas and was closely allied with the city of Houston. (Note: There exist in my files a fascinating write-up of John Day Andrews’s life and accomplishments in and around Houston which came to me through Brena, Gene and Richard.)